Search results are tailored for 2015 BMW M5 vehicles with a 4 Dr Sedan Base trim. We do this to ensure most shoppers find results as fast as possible. If your vehicle or trim is different, update it in the filters for more accurate results.

  1. Home
    2. >
  2. Shop For Tires
    3. >
  3. BMW
    4. >
  4. M5
    5. >
  5. Most Common Trim | Base
    6. > West Tisbury, MA

BMW M5 Tires in West Tisbury, MA | Your tire Size/Option: Base. How to confirm your size?

Filter Results
Close Filters

TireTutor Top Picks | The best local tire deals chosen by our proprietary algorithm

Deal Rating

Great Deal

Tire Image

Michelin - Pilot Sport AS 4

Best Seller

View Details

Best Brand

45K Miles Warranty

TireTutor Tested

Tire Size: 265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance All Season

Installed by: Cape & Islands Tire - Falmouth

Dealer Rating:

14.21 miles away

Request Information

Current Manufacturer Rebates

$314.99

$359.99 / Tire Installed

Set of 2: $719.98 + tax

All Available Tires

Tire Image

Goodyear - Eagle F1 Supercar G:2

View Details

Best Brand

Tire Size: P265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance Summer

Local Installers:

  • MV Fab & Repair LLC - 3.7 miles away
  • Courtesy Motors Incorporated - 5.2 miles away
  • Falmouth Auto Center - 14.9 miles away

Average Local Price:

$122.49

$129.87 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $519.48 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Toyo - Proxes Sport

View Details

Better Brand

25K Miles Warranty

Tire Size: 265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance Summer

Local Installers:

  • Autoeuropa - 5.5 miles away
  • NAPA Auto Parts - Auto Parts of Cape Cod - 12.8 miles away
  • AutoZone Auto Parts - 12.8 miles away

Average Local Price:

$256.09

$258.84 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1035.36 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Firestone - Firehawk Indy 500

View Details

Better Brand

Tire Size: 265/40R19W

Tire Category: Summer

Local Installers:

  • NAPA Auto Parts - E West Enterprises Inc - 5.3 miles away
  • Truck And Auto Mobile Repair MV - 7.0 miles away
  • Curtis Automotive - 14.7 miles away

Average Local Price:

$280.13

$298.64 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1194.56 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Bridgestone - Potenza RE980AS Plus

View Details

Best Brand

50K Miles Warranty

Tire Size: 265/40R19W

Tire Category: Performance All Season

Local Installers:

  • 5 Star truck & Auto mobile - 6.0 miles away
  • Midas - 13.5 miles away
  • Falmouth Auto Center - 14.9 miles away

Average Local Price:

$303.75

$318.30 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1273.20 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Nitto - NT555 G2

View Details

Better Brand

Tire Size: 265/40R19W

Tire Category: Performance Summer

Local Installers:

  • J. Deb's Garage Inc. - 5.5 miles away
  • AutoZone Auto Parts - 12.8 miles away
  • Falmouth Motorcar - 14.2 miles away

Average Local Price:

$307.01

$327.04 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1308.16 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Michelin - Pilot Sport AS 4

Best Seller

View Details

Best Brand

45K Miles Warranty

TireTutor Tested

Tire Size: 265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance All Season

Local Installers:

  • Dukes County Customs - 6.7 miles away
  • AutoZone Auto Parts - 12.8 miles away
  • Falmouth Glass and Mirror Co. - 13.9 miles away

Average Local Price:

$328.92

$352.03 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1408.12 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Hankook - Ventus S1 evo3 K127

View Details

Best Brand

Tire Size: 265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Summer

Local Installers:

  • The Vineyard Window Film Company - 2.5 miles away
  • L Yorke-Mb-Only State Rd - 3.4 miles away
  • Cape & Islands Tire - 14.2 miles away

Average Local Price:

$335.48

$369.12 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1476.48 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Continental - ExtremeContact Sport 2

View Details

Best Brand

30K Miles Warranty

Tire Size: P265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance Summer

Local Installers:

  • Truck And Auto Mobile Repair MV - 7.0 miles away
  • Curtis Automotive - 14.7 miles away
  • Curtis Truck Repair - 14.7 miles away

Average Local Price:

$367.86

$390.47 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1561.88 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Goodyear - Eagle F1 Supercar 3

View Details

Best Brand

Tire Size: 265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance Summer

Local Installers:

  • Vineyard Performance - 5.5 miles away
  • Al Noyes Automotive - 8.0 miles away
  • Falmouth Auto Center - 14.9 miles away

Average Local Price:

$370.22

$390.31 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1561.24 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Yokohama - Advan A052

View Details

Best Brand

Tire Size: 265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance Summer

Local Installers:

  • Andrea’s Auto - 6.1 miles away
  • Valvoline Instant Oil Change - 12.3 miles away
  • M&N Autorepair - 14.1 miles away

Average Local Price:

$372.39

$386.73 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1546.92 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Bridgestone - Potenza RE760 Sport

View Details

Best Brand

Tire Size: 265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance Summer

Local Installers:

  • 5 Star truck & Auto mobile - 6.0 miles away
  • Truck And Auto Mobile Repair MV - 7.0 miles away
  • NAPA Auto Parts - Auto Parts of Cape Cod - 12.8 miles away

Average Local Price:

$386.74

$405.05 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1620.20 + tax

View Details
Tire Image

Goodyear - Eagle F1 Supercar 3R

View Details

Best Brand

Tire Size: 265/40R19Y

Tire Category: Performance Summer

Local Installers:

  • Dukes County Customs - 6.7 miles away
  • NJ deBettencourt & Sons - 7.7 miles away
  • B & B Auto - 12.3 miles away

Average Local Price:

$397.12

$413.30 / Tire Installed

Set of 4: $1653.20 + tax

View Details